On Thanksgiving, the value of bringing honest truths to our tables

Some months ago, I found myself walking on one of my favorite trails with a friend… one we had walked on many times before.

This time, it was different. 

The words she was saying hurt so much: 

“Every time we meet, you seem worried about things, and you want support and advice. It’s tiring!” she explained. “I just want to have fun, and you’re so serious!”

I shouldn’t have been surprised, but recalling this moment even now feels like a gut punch. 

I was nauseous with grief. Something had died—a long-time friendship.

But let me back up.

Years ago, I saw my friend Z. a few times a week. Then life changed, we both got busier, and I saw her a lot less.

I tried to stay in touch, and after a while I realized it was mostly me making the effort. 

I needed clarity: Was she just busy, or was something more going on? 

So in early spring, I asked her to meet me for a walk, because as uncomfortable as I knew the truth might be, I knew it would be better to just know. 

A short while into the conversation, I understood more about how she was feeling. And I had one more direct question for her: Was there a way forward for our friendship?

She didn’t think so. It truly hurt so much. And yet, the conversation was oddly freeing. This is why this person is treating me like this. I can let her go.

Over the past months, I’ve been on a journey to make sense of all of this.

I read about ten books (!) on friendship—because for me, every experience is an opportunity for learning and growth. I took time to process the experience. I reflected more on what happened, on attachment styles, and what different people need from friendships.

I spoke with other friends about the friendship breakup. They were supportive. I have been consciously reaching out to new people, planting seeds for new friends.

Most deeply, I reflected on who I am. I like to laugh, have fun with friends and family, and I have a serious and reflective side. If someone does not want to accept that, they’re not the right person for me. If my needs for connection are not met, it does not feel like an authentic friendship. 

Why am I sharing this at Thanksgiving?

ID: An orange pie on a dark green background

A few years ago, I wrote a Thanksgiving post inspired by an NPR segment I’d heard on Teaching Thanksgiving; on ways to be honest about the past and how it led to the present. In that post, I shared:

“Those areas that we don’t want to talk about contain a lot of energy. My clients need someone to hold that energy so they bring me in as an outside facilitator. But when we look at those truths together, the path forward opens up.”

This experience with my friend brought this back for me. Only when we’re willing to be honest about circumstances, past and present—pain and loss, included—can we also be honest about the possibilities for moving forward. In our friendship, the path was clear. 

And in organizations, revealing truths that haven’t been talked about amongst leadership and staff can also provide clarity on potential next steps, and in many cases, leads to eventual gratitude as people feel seen and recognized, and relationships deepen. 

Leadership, and gratitude, does not need to be saccharine or marshmallow sweet 

This year has been a roller coaster ride. Many of us are feeling celebratory with the results of the midterm elections in the United States.

And for many of us, that is also tinged with the grief and rage of the destructiveness towards the past two years.

I tend to feel rebellious towards any holiday that demands a certain feeling. What if I don’t feel exactly that way?

Then I remind myself: You can hold two seemingly contradictory feelings at once.

I can grieve my friendship, and be grateful for what it gave me over the past decade.

We can be filled with rage about the past two years of destruction in our country, and feel hope about its future.

And we can sit around the Thanksgiving table with our family and feel sadness about the truth behind this holiday, while being filled with gratitude for it bringing us together now.

This year, I truly am grateful for many blessings: My parents, in their eighties, will prepare much of the food. Our two children will join us. Some extended family will be there too, with vegetables, pie, and other bounty. I published a book this year and The Ross Collective has had a strong year and the opportunity to work with some terrific partners and leaders… and more fabulous projects are slotted for 2027.

Opening up space at our tables

A more honest conversation at the Thanksgiving dinner would open up some space for the hard things that happened this year—to us personally, to our communities, to our nation, to our planet.

It’s all here in the room and at our tables, if we’re willing to talk about it.

I hope you’re able to find gratitude in at least a handful of things from this tumultuous year. And, if you’re feeling all of this—joy and gratitude, mixed with some concern or grief—I appreciate you and I see you. And I hope you will find some space for yourself to feel all of these things at your table.

We’ve published several posts about Thanksgiving in the past—and my perspective on gratitude has stayed fairly consistent! Read more: 

Next
Next

Want to clarify what your team can actually manage in 2027? Try RACI